The organist, who teases the ivories with more enthusiasm than accuracy, begins the first few notes of Silent Night. Voices…young, old, loud, soft, good, and bad… join in with a sweet sentiment the rest of the year lacks.
I’m sitting in my childhood church surrounded by people I’ve known seemingly forever, and I can’t finish the first verse of Silent Night. Or the second, or the third.  Every time I try I sense my grandmother’s spirit next to me, I smell the lemon drops in her pocket, and I feel the soft wool of her ancient black coat brushing against my arm.  Silent Night was not only her favorite Christmas song, but my mother’s as well, and it hurts that I will never hear their voices again. The emotions of loss pull so hard that I have to stop, swallow back tears, and be silent too.
My great-grandfather started the Giese Immanuel Lutheran church somewhere around 1905, I believe.  He uprooted his young family from fertile North Dakota farmland and made the laborious journey east by horse and wagon.  Grandma told me of the hardships, the work,  the booms and the busts. But her father never waivered from his vision. He started a general store, a post office, and of course, a church where family and community could gather.
I myself was baptized in that church, attended Sunday school, squirmed on the hard wooden pews when sermons seemed like endless blah-blah-blah torture instead of inspirational messages, took confirmation classes, and attended countless potluck meals in the dank, coffee-scented, church basement.
Now, firmly entrenched in adulthood—and then some!—my husband and I mostly come back for Christmas Eve services as well as the occasional wedding and funeral. While the reason for coming back to this small country church changes, the feeling that I am a part of something unique and special does not.  My family heritage is in each lemon oil-polished board, pew, and rail. I feel like I straddle the past and the present when I hold the thick red hymnal with the yellowing pages in my hands, and my being fills with love.
Grandma always spoke in German when she didn’t want me to know what she was saying, or when she was reaching back into her own childhood memories. Even now, in 2012, the Giese church ministers sing Silent Night in German before asking the congregation to join in for the English version. I try to sing, to honor Grandma and Mom, but can’t do it.
In my silence I listen for them. As the congregation lifts their voices on a cold Minnesota night, I take comfort from the echoes of Christmases past.
Stille Nacht, heilige Nacht,
Alles schläft; einsam wacht
Nur das traute hochheilige Paar.
Holder Knabe im lockigen Haar,
Schlaf in himmlischer Ruh!
Claudia says
My mother had an extraordinary singing voice. She was quiet and self-effacing, but when she sang, she soared. I always accompanied her, and with the lack of grace of youth, I groused about it too often. A few years ago I heard Arlo sing this song and it moved me to tears and brought my mother back to me in such detail. Your essay reminded me of that experience, so I wanted to share the lyrics of this song written by Woody Guthrie.
I Hear You Sing Again
Words and Music by Woody Guthrie and Janis Ian
If I could only hear my mother sing again
If I could close my eyes and hear your voice as then
All the friends and family
would sing along with me,
and set your spirit free
In my heart I hear you sing again
Every note as natural as then
and when I sing those songs
for family and friends,
in my heart I hear you sing again
I know the troubled times that turned your hair to grey
And all the tears and sorrows followed to your grave
But deep within the heart of hunger,
there were always melodies
passed from you and me
In my heart I hear you sing again
Every note as natural as then
and when I sing those songs
for family and friends,
in my heart I hear you sing again
And it’s a long, long road I’ve come
since my mother’s songs were heard
But the child I can’t outrun
still hangs on every word
In my heart I hear you sing again
Every note as natural as then
and when I sing those songs
for family and friends,
in my heart I hear you sing again
In my heart I hear your voice again
Gail says
Simply, utterly, beautiful. Thank you, Claudia.
-Gail
Leah says
Beautiful detailed writting. Reading this makes me feel like I was there. Missed you guys!
Love,
L
Gail says
Hey!
I heard you were in far away places! Welcome back, and we’d love to hear about your adventures when you get time. Here’s to hoping you’ll have a much, much, happier 2013.
Hugs,
Gail